2010 BMW X5 FUEL/PROPULSION SYSTEM

I HAVE BEEN HAVING CHECK ENGINE LIGHT (CEL) PROBLEMS FOR YEARS. HAVE BEEN TOLD IT WAS FROM THE EGR SYSTEM. BMW FIRST CHARGED ME OVER $1500 FOR A REPAIR THAT DID NOT WORK. THEN THEY REPLACED THE WHOLE SYSTEM AND SAID IT WAS "UNDER WARRANTY" WHEN THE PROBLEM RESURFACED . NOW THE DIAGNOSTICS ARE AGAIN SAYING THE EGR SYSTEM IS FAULTING AND CAUSING THE CEL AGAIN. I FEEL BMW NEEDS TO RECALL THIS SYSTEM AND CONTINUALLY REPAIR IT AS IT IS AN ENGINEERING FAULT OF THEIRS

THIS VEHICLE HAS HAD AN OPEN RECALL 18V-336 SINCE MAY OF 2018 . THE VEHICLE MANUFACTURER HAS YET TO PROVIDE A REMEDY TO CORRECT THIS DANGEROUS DEFECT IN THE VEHICLE. WHEN WILL A REMEDY BE PROVIDED? IT SEEM ALMOST A YEAR WOULD BE ENOUGH TIME TO FIX THIS DEFECT .

I PURCHASED A CAR IN 2/4/2017, ON SECOND DRIVING, THE CAR STALL ON THE GREEN LIGHT. I DID CONTACT DEALERSHIP NAMED SHARPEST RIDES, TO ASK WHAT CAUSE THE PROBLEM, AS THEY TOLD ME TO DROP CAR AT THEIR PLACE TO INVESTIGATE AND DIAGNOSIS. I DID DROP, AFTER DAY THEY CONTACT ME AND MENTIONED THAT THEY CANNOT DUPLICATE THE PROBLEM, BECAUSE NOT ENOUGH TOOLS, SO THEY REFER TO BMW OF DENVER DOWNTOWN. THE BMW DEALER DID TEST AND DIAGNOSIS OF COUPLE DAYS AND RESPOND WITH "WE CANNOT DUPLICATE OF PROBLEM", SO THEY RETURN MY CAR TO ME WITH UNSAFE CONDITION. AFTER WHILE I STARTING HAVE SAME PROBLEM WITH STALL ENGINE IN THE MIDDLE OF ROAD, AT PARKING LOT, OR ONE DAY WASN'T EVEN START ENGINE, OR WHEN CAR STALL AND I AM LUCKY THE GUY DIDN'T HIT ME IN THE BACK, BUT HE DID HORNED ON ME, SHOWED ME FINGER, AND SO ON. I DID CONTACT MULTIPLE TIMES WITH DEALERSHIPS, WITH CORPORATE HEADQUARTER AT US NORTH AMERICA AND DID HAVE A CHANCE OPEN A CASE, HAVE A CHANCE TALK TO SUPERVISING, BUT EVERYONE SAYING TO ME BECAUSE CAR DIDN'T SHOWED ERROR MASSAGE AND THEY CANNOT DUPLICATE PROBLEM THEY WONT REPLACE FUEL PUMP, EVEN THEY KNEW THIS IS A FUEL PUMP CAUSING A PROBLEM. IN ADDITION, THEY DID RECALL 136000 FUEL PUMP, BUT THEY DIDN'T WANT CHANGE NOW, AND I DID TRY EXPLAIN THEM EVERYDAY WE ARE ON THE ROAD, WE MUST KEEP OUR LIFE SAFE AND KEEP OUR ENVIRONMENT SAFE, BUT THEY STILL TELLING ME WE CANNOT DUPLICATE A PROBLEM. MY CAR WAS A SECOND TIME AT SAME DEALERSHIP ON 4/72017 WITH SAME PROBLEM, AND THEY STILL TELLING ME EVERYTHING FINE WITH YOUR CAR, JUST DRIVE, I HAVE FOUR WITNESS THAT CAN VERBALLY IN WRITING PROOF THAT MY CAR STALL. MAYBE THE CAR IS DRIVE-ABLE BUT UNSAFE, BECAUSE YOU CANNOT PREDICT WHERE IT CAN BE STOP. PLEASE REVIEW AND SEE IF MANUFACTURE OR DEALERSHIP FOLLOWING ON ALL SAFETY PROCEDURE TO LET PEOPLE DRIVE IN HIGH RISK AND DANGEROUS OF LIFE ON ROAD. PLEASE CALL ME [XXX]. THANK YOU INFORMATION REDACTED PURSUANT TO THE FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT (FOIA), 5 U.S.C. 552(B)(6). *TR

TL* THE CONTACT OWNS A 2010 BMW X5. WHILE DRIVING 30 MPH, THE ENGINE SHOOK, SMOKE APPEARED, AND THE ENGINE STALLED. THERE WAS NO FIRE. THE ENGINE MALFUNCTION INDICATOR ILLUMINATED. THE VEHICLE WAS TOWED TO BMW OF DENVER DOWNTOWN (1040 S COLORADO BLVD, DENVER, CO 80246 (303) 954-4856) WHERE IT DIAGNOSED THAT THE SECONDARY FUEL PUMP AND THE FUEL INJECTORS NEEDED TO BE REPLACED. THE VEHICLE WAS REPAIRED. THE MANUFACTURER WAS NOT NOTIFIED OF THE FAILURE. THE FAILURE MILEAGE WAS 53,220.

I HAD THE FUEL HEATER REPLACED AND BATTERY ON MY BMW X5-35D A COUPLE OF MONTHS AGO AT CONSIDERABLE COST. THE ENGINE WAS ALSO THROWING THE FUEL HEATER ACTIVATION CODE. I HAVE DOCUMENTATION OF THE REPAIR. I HAVE RECENTLY LEARNED OF RECALL 13V-339 THAT COVERS THIS PART FOR THIS EXACT REASON WITH A BUILD DATE WINDOW MERE WEEKS FROM THE BUILD DATE OF MY VEHICLE. THE BUILD DATE RANGE ON THIS RECALL IS JUNE 13, 2009- NOVEMBER 9, 2009. THE BUILD DATE FOR MY VIN IS LISTED AS DECEMBER 2009. BMW DID NOT COVER DESPITE THE PROXIMITY OF THE BUILD DATE AND THE EXACT SAME PROBLEM. I CAN SEE THAT THERE ARE OTHER COMPLAINTS ON THE NHTSA.DOT.GOV WEBSITE FOR THIS PROBLEM FOR VEHICLES WITH A DECEMBER 2009 BUILD DATE'

THE FUEL FILTER HEATER WAS RECALLED (RECALL NO. 13V-339). WE HAD TO HAVE OUR FUEL FILTER HEATER REPLACED AND WAS NOT COVERED UNDER WARRANTY BECAUSE THE RECALL WAS FOR VEHICLES PRODUCED FROM 6/2009 - 11/2009 AND OUR CAR WAS PRODUCED IN 12/2009. WE HAD OUR FUEL FILTER HEATER REPLACED BECAUSE WE HAD A CHECK ENGINE LIGHT ON AND WHEN WE TOOK TO DEALER WE WERE TOLD THAT WE NEEDED A NEW FUEL FILTER HEATER, THEREFORE WE FEEL WE ARE INTITLLED TO THE RECALL.

TL* THE CONTACT OWNS A 2010 BMW X5. WHILE DRIVING AT VARIOUS SPEEDS, FUEL WAS LEAKING UNDER THE FRONT OF THE VEHICLE WITHOUT WARNING. THE VEHICLE WAS TAKEN TO A DEALER WHERE IT WAS DIAGNOSED THAT THE TIMING COVER CASES FAILED AND NEEDED TO BE REPLACED. THE VEHICLE WAS NOT REPAIRED. THE MANUFACTURER WAS NOT NOTIFIED OF THE FAILURE. THE FAILURE MILEAGE WAS APPROXIMATELY 82,000.